|
Was this email forwarded to you? Sign up here. |
 |
|
Good morning and happy Friday,
Fuel prices are proving to be one issue incumbents can't escape with the midterms less than two weeks out, and electricity bills are close behind. Heatmap found that "September bills in competitive Republican-held districts have risen by a median of 21% between 2024 and 2026," while the New York Times visited a small town in Oklahoma where families are having their power cut off.
That affordability squeeze sits in awkward opposition to what's being spent to talk about it. Political ad spending has reached what the Times calls "breathtaking" levels, passing $10 billion this week and on track for $11.6 billion by Election Day. President Trump has joined the fray with an unprecedented $277 million from his MAGA, Inc. super PAC in the final stretch.
The Russian diesel deal continues to make headlines. A House Democrat introduced legislation to block it, and "a growing chorus of House Republicans" is warning that the president needs to get tougher with Russia or risk losing additional Pentagon funding. The President answered the diesel criticism with $8 billion in aid to farmers hurt by high fuel prices.
And Stateline has made it official: forget the dot-com and railroad booms. The $10.3 trillion data center buildout is now the largest financial bet in U.S. history, expected to carry almost twice the economic impact of the late-1800s railroad expansion at nearly 4% of GDP.
|
 |
It's Not the Money, It's the Structure
For clean energy developers, the local permit remains one of the biggest hurdles between a signed lease and a shovel in the ground. A new RMI study of more than 200 utility-scale solar, wind, and storage projects, representing $66 billion in investment, lands on a finding that should change how benefit packages get designed: the projects that won their permits did not offer communities more money than the projects that lost. They offered it in a form residents could see, trust, and control. Here's what the data shows:
-
The 8% that didn't matter. Successful projects averaged roughly $232,500/MW in lifetime local benefits. Failed projects averaged $214,600/MW. On a 150-MW project, that's $34.9 million versus $32.2 million, a gap too small to explain why one got built and the other didn't. Total payout is not the variable.
-
Taxes and leases don't register with residents. Nearly two-thirds of failed projects relied mainly on property tax revenue and landowner payments to deliver value. Both are real money, but residents experience them as indirect, variable, or absorbed into the county's general fund. By contrast, 60% of permitted projects layered additional mechanisms on top of taxes, such as PILOTs, host community agreements, and community benefit agreements, that put value in front of a broader set of neighbors.
-
Direct funding nearly doubles the odds. Community benefit agreements, host community agreements, or direct community funding showed up in 43% of successful projects versus 24% of failed ones. PILOT agreements, which turn a variable tax bill into a predictable long-term payment, appeared in 25% of successful projects versus 15% of failed ones.
-
The test is three questions. RMI boils it down to whether a benefit is direct (is the connection between the project and the money obvious?), visible (can every host community member see and understand what they're getting?), and controllable (who decides how it's spent: the landowner, the county, or the community itself?). Projects that could answer all three cleanly fared far better.
⚡️ The Takeaway
Delivery matters as much as dollars. Benefit design can't resolve every local impact or ideological objection, and RMI is careful to say so. But the pattern across 200 projects is hard to argue with: the developers who got permitted moved past the standard tax-and-lease model and structured value so residents could actually feel it. A benefit the community doesn't know about doesn't count. Use the $/MW benchmarks as a floor, then spend the design effort on making the money direct, itemized, and locally controlled. It's the third study in six weeks, after the Sabin Center's opposition count and EPRI's battery safety data, to land on the same conclusion from a different angle: the gap between what developers offer and what the room perceives is where projects are won and lost. |
 |
Duke Opens the Door, a Crack
North Carolina's clean energy market may be on the verge of a real opening. After years of hyperscalers pushing for dedicated 24/7 carbon-free power, Duke Energy has pledged to begin formal negotiations early next year on a long-sought "clean transition tariff" (CTT). A promise to talk isn't a tariff, and advocates are saying so. But it's the most significant movement yet toward letting corporate buyers directly fund new zero-carbon generation on Duke's grid. Here's what you need to know:
-
The commitment is a process, not a product. Duke confirmed it will launch stakeholder talks in early 2027 to explore a CTT, building on its existing Green Source Advantage program, which lets large energy users pay a premium for new zero-carbon resources.
-
The big buyers didn't get it in the settlement. Google, Meta, Microsoft, Amazon, and the Corporate Energy Buyers Association have been lobbying hard for "bring-your-own-clean-energy" rules. The large load tariff Duke and those companies agreed to was submitted to the North Carolina Utilities Commission earlier this month without any CTT provisions.
-
It's a ratepayer argument, not just a sustainability one. Proponents emphasize that a CTT shields residential customers from the financial risk of Duke overbuilding fossil infrastructure to serve data center growth, since corporate buyers would carry the cost of the new resources they want.
-
A promise to talk isn't an order. Environmental groups welcomed the announcement but want it enforced. As Will Scott of the Environmental Defense Fund put it, "We need enforceable direction from the Utilities Commission to make sure this leads to a real, on-the-books outcome that saves North Carolina households money."
⚡️ The Takeaway
All eyes on the regulators. A working clean transition tariff would open a real market for developers: a direct path to creditworthy corporate offtakers eager to underwrite new renewables, storage, and firm clean power through Duke RFPs. The NCUC is expected to rule on Duke's large load proposal by mid-November, and advocates will push the commission to put the CTT on a firm timeline rather than leave it to stakeholder talks that don't start until 2027. Developers with North Carolina pipeline should treat the next two years as the window to position projects for what those talks produce.
|
 |
Permitting Reform
The Dominion–NextEra Merger
Data Centers
Markets, Storage, and Everything Else
|
 |
|
|
 |
8.7 Seconds of Glory
A prototype generator sitting a mile underwater, 300 miles off the Oregon coast, ran for 29 seconds last month before a software glitch tripped its safety system. For 8.7 of those seconds, it made more electricity than it used. In the world of subsea geothermal, that counts as a win.
The company behind it is Endurance Energy, a two-year-old startup led by former SpaceX engineer Andrew Redd, whose stated ethos is "make it exist, then make it good." The plan was to drill the world's first subsea geothermal well into an underwater volcano and run a 100-kilowatt generator for a full year. After losing days to drill repairs, the team pivoted to a natural hydrothermal vent and got the unit running long enough to prove the concept: for nearly nine seconds, its output exceeded the 7 to 8 kilowatts needed to run its own onboard pumps and hardware, yielding about 2 kilowatts of surplus.
|
 |
|
Backed by $63 million in venture capital, Endurance plans to redeploy a refurbished unit this winter, targeting sustained power from a much deeper well, ahead of a 2-MW commercial pilot supplying the grid in Tonga by the end of 2027. Not everyone is convinced. Emily Pope, a geologist and senior fellow at the Center for Climate and Energy Solutions, called it "an eyebrow-raising approach" given the brutal mechanics, sky-high costs, and corrosive saltwater involved in deep-sea engineering.
But the prize is large. A conference paper from geoscience firm Viridien estimates offshore geothermal could yield roughly 6 terawatts of recoverable 24/7 baseload power worldwide, much of it along the Pacific "Ring of Fire" within reach of major coastal markets. Nine seconds is a long way from that. It's also nine seconds more than anyone had before.
|
|
Thanks for diving into the Developer Dispatch with us.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Building American power requires a powerful team. |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|